Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

--- project:legal:openprivacypolicy [2013/09/19 11:20] – [Open Privacy Policy] rbinns
+++ project:legal:openprivacypolicy [2013/09/30 10:04] (current) – loleg
@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-This is a [[event:2013-09|LegalHack@OKCon 2013]] challenge
+====== Open Privacy Legislation ======
-====== Open Privacy Policy ======
+The web holds enormous potential to make legislation openly available as a public resource. Not just so you can read pieces of legislation online, but also to analyse, annotate, combine and reference using new tools. The [[http://www.openingparliament.org/declaration|Declaration of Parliamentary Openness]] was released in 2012. It lays out a set of best practices for national parliaments to make their information open.
-The web holds enormous potential to make legislation openly available as a public resource. Not just so you can read pieces of legislation online, but also to analyse, annotate, combine and reference using new tools.
+Taking data protection and privacy legislation as a case study, we assessed a range of government websites and rated them according to a few of the criteria from the Declaration. We rated countries on a 1-4 scale based on the following criteria; is there a URI for the original act (1 point), the most current version of the act (1), is there a permissive license (1), and is the URI 'neat' (1)?
-The Declaration of Parliamentary Openness was released in 2012 (http://www.openingparliament.org/declaration ). It lays out a set of best practices for national parliaments to make their information open. Taking data protection and privacy legislation as a case study, we assessed a range of government websites and rated them according to a few of the criteria from the Declaration.
+We mapped this data: **[[http://cdb.io/19dvTYx|live demo]]**
-====== Project =====
+[[http://cdb.io/19dvTYx|{{:project:legal:open_privacy_legislation_cartodb.png?200|}}]]
-(screenshots or sketches up here)
+This project started as a [[event:2013-09|LegalHack@OKCon 2013]] challenge.
-Brief description goes here. Add sections below if you need more room.
+=== 18 Stars of Open Legislation? ===
-Include links to your demo and/or source code.
+John Sheridan also came up with a set of additional criteria, a little like Tim Berners-Lee's Five Stars of Linked Data, which set out some additional technical best practices for publishing legislation;
-===== Data =====
+Basic:
-  * List and link your actual and ideal data sources.
+  * there is a URI for each legislative act
+  * the URI resolves on the web to open legislation
-===== Team =====
+Standard:
-  * Reuben Binns
+  * the URI Set is persistent with guarantees about availability
-  * List your [[user:home|team members]] here ...
+  * Occam's razor has been applied (no cruft in the URI).
-===== Links =====
+Advanced:
+  * URI set contains abstract identifiers and document identifiers
+  * URI set supports multiple manifestations (XML, PDF)
+  * URI resolution supports content negotiation (e.g. browser can request content as plain text rather
+than html)
+  * traditional citation scheme can be mapped to new style URIs with no additional information
+  * the URIs are human readable / reader friendly
+  * the URIs are hackable
+  * there are batch and list views available as well as identifiers for documents
+  * URIs support provision level addressing
+  * URIs support point in time addressing
+  * URIs support jurisdiction variations
+  * URIs support known future states (prospective versions)
+  * URIs support possible future states (proposed versions)
+  * URIs support a variety of aliases and searches to aid use
+  * URIs are formally described with a IETF URI Template specification
+===== Data =====
+  * [[https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AlqMaTMcz6UzdHBzT05GcWpaSk92dGZIV1NLY3U0VkE&usp=sharing|Online spreadsheet]]
+===== Team =====
-  * Relevant documentation ...
+  * Reuben Binns (@rdbinns)
-  * Blog or forum posts ...
-  * Tools you used ...
-{{tag>status:concept legal needs:dev needs:design needs:data needs:expert}}
+{{tag>status:demo legal needs:dev needs:design needs:data needs:expert}}