| Both sides previous revision Previous revision Next revision | Previous revision |
| project:legal:casesuccess [2013/09/06 17:48] – [Case Success] loleg | project:legal:casesuccess [2018/11/13 14:47] (current) – [Data] alicesmith |
|---|
| ===== Case Success ===== | This is a [[event:2013-09|LegalHack@OKCon 2013]] challenge |
| |
| This is a [[event:2013-09|LegalHack@OKCon 2013]] challenge. | ====== Case Success ====== |
| |
| Every case is unique. | Every case is unique. |
| It is often difficult for a lawyer to answer one of the most pressing question of his client: What are my chances of success if we go to court (or if I plea non-guilty)? The challenge is to provide lawyers and clients with an accurate //base rate// of success or //average amount// for a similar claim. At the end of the day, the decision is always taken by a judge on the basis of the evidence and arguments in front of him. However, when you have a database of thousands of these decisions, you can start seeing trends and probablities. | It is often difficult for a lawyer to answer one of the most pressing question of his client: What are my chances of success if we go to court (or if I plea non-guilty)? The challenge is to provide lawyers and clients with an accurate //base rate// of success or //average amount// for a similar claim. At the end of the day, the decision is always taken by a judge on the basis of the evidence and arguments in front of him. However, when you have a database of thousands of these decisions, you can start seeing trends and probablities. |
| |
| Reference links and data sources: | Law case databases like [[http://www.canlii.org/en/|CanLii from Canada]] (also see [[http://beta.canlii.org/fr/international.html|Beta Site]]) offer exhaustive decisions from a certain court for a certain period of times. What kind of metadata would allow easily to compile such statistics? |
| | |
| * Law case databases like [[http://www.canlii.org/en/|CanLii from Canada]] (also see [[http://beta.canlii.org/fr/international.html|Beta Site]]) offer exhaustive decisions from a certain court for a certain period of times. What kind of metadata would allow easily to compile such statistics? | |
| |
| Example use cases: | Example use cases: |
| |
| - **Criminal law:** What is the success rate of a //right to self-defense// strategy in case of assault? What is the average sentence? How many cases go to appeal? | * **Criminal law:** What is the success rate of a //right to self-defense// strategy in case of assault? What is the average sentence? How many cases go to appeal? |
| - **Civil law:** What is the base rate of success for a criminal damage (//dommage-intérêts//) claim in case of property damages caused by a dog? In case of success, what is the average amount of criminal damage granted by the judge? | * **Civil law:** What is the base rate of success for a (//dommage-intérêts//) claim in case of property damages caused by a dog? In case of success, what is the average amount of damages granted by the judge? |
| - **Building trust:** clients of lawyers could take more well-advised decisions when it comes to "should we try to settle out of court or not" (for civil law cases). | * **Building trust:** clients of lawyers could take more well-advised decisions when it comes to "should we try to settle out of court or not" (for civil law cases). |
| - **Research**: it can be extremely valuable for policy-makers and researchers to have the ability to easily cross reference a large amount of case data. | * **Research**: it can be extremely valuable for policy-makers and researchers to have the ability to easily cross reference a large amount of case data. |
| | |
| | === Hackathon goals === |
| |
| Suggested goals: | - Create a database with parties names, status (plaintiff or defendant) and the result (who won the case); |
| | - Push the database forward by including the amount of the claim and the result; |
| | - Create a website where the user can query his chances of success; |
| |
| - What is the success rate of a "right to self-defense" defense in case of assault? (in front of a specific court, for a specific territorial jurisdiction) | We could start with these three goals regarding one specific legal action (example: civil liability claims for damages caused by an animal) in front of a specific jurisdiction (example: Cour du Québec). If the goals are too easy, the ultimate goal would be to extend to multiple legal actions or multiple jurisdictions. |
| - Identify metadata that could allow to seek this kind of information easily. Identify metadata that could allow a more granular research. | |
| - Scale the Hackday goal 1 solution to another jurisdiction. | |
| |
| ====== Project ===== | ====== Project ===== |
| Brief description of your hackday results goes here. Add sections below if you need more room. | Brief description of your hackday results goes here. Add sections below if you need more room. |
| |
| Include links to your demo and/or source code. | Include links to your demo and/or [[http://debtpro.co/debt-relief-scams-tips-to-avoid-protect/|source]] code. |
| |
| ===== Data ===== | ===== Data ===== |